Biofuels application withdrawn – for now.
Fergus Tickell of Northern Energy has withdrawn his current application by for the combined Heat and Power plant proposed for the Heights between Lamlash and Whiting Bay. However, the applicant is still fully committed to the proposed project, and a new application may be submitted later in the year.
Evidently, Mr Tickell took serious note of the points raised during the intense debate about the suitability of the project in its current form. Any new application, he promises, will include ‘a detailed report narrating the engagement process and outcomes as well as the additional information which addresses those legitimate concerns raised to date.’ Meanwhile, however, he says, ‘I formally request that Application reference 12/00282/PP is withdrawn.’
This provides a welcome breathing-space, but work on considering the proposal must continue. Arran Community Council has set up a small sub-committee that includes people with professional knowledge in the field, and is committed to producing a well-researched, detailed report. This will accompany any amended planning application that may be submitted.
While technical questions can be investigated and clarified, some of the most significant factors in the proposal are more difficult to quantify. Though intangible, the question of perception is vitally important. Arran’s main income is through tourism, and this depends on the island’s image as a place of natural beauty and clean air, far from the rush and pollution of cities. Whether or not the imagined plant would in fact have a visible chimney and a plume of vapour is almost immaterial, for the personal reaction is essentially an emotional one. This has shown up, rather disgracefully, in an ‘opposition’ poster showing a wooded glen that has nothing whatever to do with the proposed site – but it reveals psychological fears that run deeper than any ding-dong of facts.
Looking beyond the current fracas, it is obvious Arran will need to develop its own sources of renewable energy. Oil is a finite resource and will become even more expensive as remaining supplies become rarer and more valuable. We must look to the future, with energy and imagination. Micro-generation is probably the way forward, with every new-built house capable of making its own electricity. But we must also safeguard the present. Rational or not, we have to cherish the clean, beautiful image that is so vital to the island.
A reader’s letter on the subject follows further down

-170x230.jpg)


