Issue 30

Here and away

Though firmly centred on Arran and all its doings, the Voice finds itself increasingly international. This month, we have reports on a Corrie artist north of Kathmandu and a Norwegian stushie over whether children should eat farmed fish. There’s a fluorescent pink slug from Australia and a reader in Greece has thanked us for guidance on how to run a Folk Festival. Corrie Film Club is showing the Anglo-French film, Certified Copy, and we investigate the nature of the Bitcoin, a world-wide cashless currency that is gaining use among those for whom money is something larger than the means of paying the bills and staying alive.

If you or anyone you know would like to receive an e-mail on the first day of every month with an easy-click link to the latest Voice for Arran, just send us an e-mail on info@voiceforarran.com. Free, of course. We’re always grateful for the odd donation, but we’ll never ask you for money. Not even in bitcoins.

 

Art in Corrie “Yes!”

During the warm week that looked like summer, Corrie Hall blossomed into a splendid display of paintings, sculpture and creative artefacts of all kinds, while people relaxed on the grass outside in a truly Mediterranean manner. In the hall, a wonderful structure made from discarded pallets was hung with decorative mirrors that reflected countless images at slanting angles, somehow turning the place into a kind of treasure cave. The ever-inventive Marvin Elliott had constructed this, and at one end of it stood his weirdly evocative sculpture of a standing man in big boots, his torso consisting only of burned timber. “Yes,” he said, “it’s by me and the vandals.”

A rich variety of pictures lined the walls, including Tim Pomeroy’s marvellously evocative interpretation of a ruined cairn among powerful plant growth. Nicky Gill, always a wonderful colourist, showed paintings of rocks and sea that found new subtleties of reflected light, and Tracey Gibson’s study of a horse and rider in an extended trot was much admired. Her versatility knows no bounds however, and her paintings of open-eyed, daisy-like flowers were bursting with colour and invention.

The show pledged a proportion of any profits to the YES campaign for Scottish Independence, and a stall was well provided with explanatory leaflets and a quiz sheet. It also offered very handsome, simply designed ‘YES’ coffee mugs, capacious and a pleasure to use. We have not so far spotted any ‘NO’ mugs. Somehow the concept seems to lack the same cheery impact.

 

The Importance of Being Earnest at school

Last week’s three-night run of Oscar Wilde’s classic comedy, The Importance of Being Earnest, was a triumph for the High School players and their producer, Heather Johnston. Stylish, assured and lovely to look at, the production moved smoothly through the vastly wordy script and gave full value to Wilde’s mordant wit. Played for laughs, it threw in a vast amount of small business that gave every character things to do and added immensely to the fun, but there was a nod of respect for Wilde’s underlying indignation at the snobbery and massive self-indulgence of the rich. This waspish mixture has always given the play a ‘bite’ that raises it above farce level, though the overall touch remains light and totally unsentimental.

Every part, including such minor ones as the servants, demanded real stage presence, and the players rose to the challenge magnificently. Scott Barbour’s Jack had a perceptive touch of insecurity that made him the perfect foil to the cheerfully decadent Algy, brilliantly played by Chris Jenks, while Catherine McEachern was a slender, exquisitely poised and slightly waspish Gwendolyn. Katherine O’Donnelly as Cecily was pure strawberries and cream, innocent, happy and adorable, while Kirsty McAllister’s Lady Bracknell loomed like a large thunderstorm, causing ripples of terror wherever her presence was threatened. She opted for quite a fast delivery, which was not always easy to pull off while remaining magisterial, but had great presence.

Iona Flewitt, in the pivotal role of Miss Prism, pulled off a very difficult trick in being simultaneously goofy, ludicrous and deeply vulnerable. She, who has an unsuspected double depth and a hidden past, is the only one who knows why an abandoned baby was left in a handbag at Victoria station, and Iona brought a very perceptive vulnerability to the part, coupled with matchless comic timing. David Gillingham provided a solid, baffled presence at Dr Chasuble and Mollie Hodkinson played Merriman with cheerful, adroit assurance, as did Robbie Bayne, Emily Moore and Lauren McAllister, providing solid, credible supporting performances.

The starring roles were memorable. Chris Jenks, debonair, self-indulgent and ineffably light-hearted, displayed astonishing stage-craft in the difficult job of constant eating while talking. Not many people can retain ineffable charm while stuffing down muffins at top speed, but Chris could, and did. In his scenes with the beautiful Katherine O’Donnelly, the pair of them had perfectly balanced stage movement, quick and light but with absolute certainty while speaking. They both have the valued quality of stillness, and are already young professionals with a lot of experience behind them and, one feels sure, a dazzling career ahead.

Overall, everyone concerned in this production is to be congratulated. The stage build looked lovely, it was beautifully dressed and, most impressively, the massive script seemed to present no problems though everyone had done an enormous learn. An impressive achievement, and a thoroughly enjoyable evening for the packed and rapturous audience.


Certified Copy in Corrie

On Sunday, July 14th, (Bastille Day) Corrie Film Club rather suitably shows a French-English film made in 2010 by the Iranian director Abbas Kiarostami, starring Juliette Binoche. It’s set in Tuscany, to add to its many visual joys.

A visiting British author called James Miller, played by William Shimell, is promoting his latest book, called Certified Copy, which puts forward the idea that a copy of a work of art is just as valid as the original thing. Binoche, as a French antiques dealer, has been invited to his talk and is both irritated and fascinated by this handsome celebrity. Her teenage son is not fascinated at all, and is prickly and difficult. In a local café, their bickering leads the proprietor to take them for a married couple.

The writer and the antique dealer are amused by the idea and start to act out a scenario in which the imagined pair explore their tensions and resentments. They thus enter into an unreal reality of their own invention, thus providing a living example of what James is writing about. Can a copy of reality be as valid as the real thing? This strange film, which switches languages between French and English, is an oddity, but a very intriguing and intelligent one.

The showing begins at 8.00pm in Corrie Hall, and all are welcome, free of charge, though contributions to help meet the hall's expenses are always welcome.

 

The story of golf on Arran

Jim Henderson continues his series.

The sport of golf came to Arran in the late 19th century, roughly 125 years ago, made possible by the new boats and the new trade that they introduced. Prior to that, the only means of travelling to Arran from Bute or Saltcoats was by ‘Wherry-built’ nutshells known as ‘Flyboats’ or ‘Packets’. These little sailing craft also carried two to three pairs of oars, and when weather conditions were not good for sailing, paying passengers were expected to man the oars. The service was irregular, and at best was weekly rather than daily.

Glasgow, however, was slowly developing as an international port. U.K. Legislation permitted merchants to import tobacco, sugar, timber and other goods from America, the Caribbean and other parts of the world, and the River Clyde was busy with sailing schooners coming in from distant places. It was all set for expansion, and two men born in Scotland were already working on a technical revolution that would change travel for all time.

The first was James Watt of Greenock (1736-1819), who improved the early Newcomen steam engine by inventing a separate condensing chamber and revolutionised the navigation of the world. The second was Henry Bell (1767-1830) who lived in Helensburgh. He and Watt can be said to have begun the industrial age of Britain. Watt commissioned the building of a timber craft powered by a steam engine, built by John Wood of Port Glasgow and named the P.S. Comet, which was launched in 1812 and named after the great comet of 1811, which was visible from March until September. John Robertson and David Napier of Glasgow built the steam-powered engine, which drove side-mounted paddles. This, the first of many paddle steamers, was introduced to the public in August and began a passenger service between Glasgow and Greenock. Later, she was chartered to sail north to Oban and Fort William via the Crinan Canal (designed by engineer John Rennie and opened in 1801.) The Comet was shipwrecked at Craignish Point in December 1820, but her success had inspired other shipyards in the upper Clyde to build steam-powered craft.

With passenger and freight services sailing from the Broomielaw to various locations in the Clyde estuary, entrepreneurs constructed piers and hotels or large boarding houses to accommodate the increasing numbers of holiday-makers from Glasgow. Small villages like Helensburgh, Dunoon, Rothesay, Millport and Largs soon became towns.

Arran was left out of all this development because of the controls exercised by the 8th and 9th Duke of Hamilton 1769 - 1819. At the turn of the 18th century there was no island road structure and visitors were seen as a nuisance rather than a potential asset. The Duke and his trustees discouraged excursion traffic and exercised controls on the number of people permitted to stay even for short periods. Fueing of land to people who wanted to build houses was also discouraged, which in turn delayed the development being seen elsewhere in the Firth of Clyde. Arran was at the time described as the most ‘unspoiled’ part of the Clyde area, but it was probably also the most disadvantaged. As Alan Paterson wrote, ‘The Duke is the absolute Lord whose word is undisputed.’ To be fair, the situation was not easy. The population of Arran was at an all-time high of around 6,000 persons and the island was in no position to support or feed additional people. Such pastimes as golf had never been thought of.

Things began to change in August 1825 when the Helensburgh began a scheduled service to Arran from Greenock, calling at Rothesay and Lochranza, then down the east side of the island to Lamlash, returning via Brodick, Millport and Largs. The trip took all day, and passengers and goods were ferried to the shore by local rowing boats. Four years later, in 1829, the Royal Mail Steam Packet Co began a weekly service from Greenock to all villages on the east coast of Arran, using with paddle steamers named Inverary Castle and Toward. That same year, a sailing brig left Arran for Canada, laden with people hoping for some new chance to make a living.

Twelve months later, the Ardrossan Steamboat Co commissioned the paddle steamer Earl of Arran to begin a daily service between Ardrossan, Brodick and Lamlash. By this time there were 66 piers and quays serving the paddle steamer traffic in the Clyde estuary

It was not until 1872 that the Estate built the first serviceable pier on Arran at Brodick. After a short-lived attempt to run a passenger service, it approached Captain Buchanan, who commissioned the PS Brodick Castle andalso built the house called Kinneil, which can still be seen in Lamlash. The pier at Lamlash, built with green heart timber, was opened for traffic in 1884, and five years later, the longest pier on the Clyde was built at Whiting Bay.

Tourism was at last developing. Hotels were being built on Arran to accommodate the holidaymakers and families made their homes available as guesthouses, offering part or full board. The visitors brought with them various types of sporting equipment including golf clubs. There were no golf courses, but the visitors practised on the village greens or on harvested fields. Any open area was seized on to strike the small white ‘guttie’ balls, and local people became curious. Very quickly, they, too, wanted to participate in this new sport.

 

Musical treats to come

Advance notice of two fabulous concerts in August.

Joy Dunlop - world-famous Gaelic singer and step-dancer

Joy Dunlop, a multi-award-winning singer and dancer, will be in Brodick Hall on Thursday 8th August with Patsy Reid on violin and Paul Tracey on guitar. They offer a fabulous programme of Gaelic music and song in the contemporary style that has made her a top performer at international festivals throughout the world. She moves easily from unaccompanied love songs to vigorous ‘work-music’ and from Celtic lament to inspired and foot-rattling Scottish dancing. This is a phenomenally exciting group, and tickets at the knock-down price of a mere £8.00 are already selling.

Full details will appear in next month’s Voice, but if you would like to make sure of your tickets in advance, go to www.arrevents.com where you can easily book online.

Jimmy Moon and the Rose Room

Jimmy Moon, well known to countless people on Arran, is equally fabulous. He will be making a rare return to the island on Saturday August 24th, when his Rose Room quartet will be playing in Whiting Bay hall. This laid-back, smooth, utterly professional jazz group was one of the first to play Swing music in the Gypsy Jazz style of the great Django Reinhardt and Stephane Grappelli, and remains supreme. Featuring violins, guitars, vocals and double bass, this exciting acoustic has immense charisma, moving easily from heart-touching songs to ‘Hot Club’ jazz and Western Swing. This is a unique chance to hear the Rose Room, and for Jimmy Moon, it is a return home. A big event, not to be missed.

Tickets at £10 are available now from www.arrevents.com and more details of the concerts will appear in next month�s Voice.

 

June update on our fundraising for the Butterfly Tree charity.

June has been a busy month in our campaign to raise money for the Butterfly Tree charity. We are helping to buy mosquito nets for the children of Zambia for protection against malaria. At Hazelbank we held our annual plant sale weekend but this year we served tea and cake and asked for donations for the charity. The weather was on our side and we raised over £70.00 for the charity. I write regular updates on my blog Scottish island mum and so we now have people all over the country making our little tulle butterflies to sell and hosting charity tea parties of their own.

Our butterfly tree, full of gorgeous butterflies, will be popping up at various events during the summer including the Victorian day at the castle and the Highland Games. Do come and say hello and we can tell you the very latest news. We are grateful to Bay News and Gifts in Whiting Bay for dedicating a shelf to the charity so we can all purchase from a range of butterfly inspired gifts. All the proceeds from these gifts go to the charity. We are looking for more outlets on the island so if you could find a small corner in your shop or cafe please do get in touch.

Lastly, we have set the date for the end of campaign Butterfly Supper. Coast in Whiting Bay is hosting the event in Tuesday 10th September at 7pm. Our little team of fundraisers are busy planning the evening which promises to be a lot of fun. We will welcome you with a Buck's Fizz before serving a wonderful two course buffet. Little gems of entertainment throughout the evening are being planned as well as a 'pledge' raffle. Tickets cost £25.00 pp and from that £5.00 will go to the charity to purchase one net. Tickets will be on sale from the end of July from Bay News and Gifts, Coast or from ourselves. There will only be 40 available so do make sure you get one. It will be lovely to see you.

Continued thanks to all the butterfly helpers.
The Doubleday family
fionadoubleday@me.com

 

The terrifying Bitcoin

When international banking went pear-shaped, we began to see what a gulf there is between real money and the notional kind. Real money is geared to what you have actually earned, and a step over the limit brings you instant punishment. Notional money uses no banknotes, coinage or chequebooks and recognises no restrictions. It’s the stuff that Osborne invents at a computer stroke and calls Quantitative Easing - a form of pure mathematics.

The problem has always been that pure money values are skewed if someone puts a foot wrong in the real-money world. As we’ve seen, over-ambitious investment in Icelandic banks undid the system, as a sack gapes open when you pull one end of the stitching along the top. Within a few months of this happening, a ‘peer-to-peer electronic cash system’ arrived, based on an imagined unit called the Bitcoin. It works like a kind of PayPal, only free. A trader in London can send half a million quid to Moscow instantly, for no charge. Such a mutually beneficial system cannot be regulated or taxed, so traders love it.

The idea is not new. For a long time, communities have used small-scale Local Trading Currencies such as the Bristol pound. The Greeks were quick to invent a drachma/Euro substitute to circumvent the pressure of the EU. But the Bitcoin is far bigger than that, and growing fast. A site called Longbets.org predicts that it will ‘outperform the US Dollar, Gold, Silver, and the stock market by over 100 times over the next two years.’

The US government is frantically trying to shove the genie back into the bottle, complaining that the Bitcoin serves the interests of illegal traders such as drug dealers. This is true, but on the moral high ground, people are pointing out that if we all used the Bitcoin, governments could never again force us to pay for wars that we don’t support. But neither could they levy taxes or exercise financial control of any kind. The Bitcoin is the beginning of systematised anarchy, a space to be watched with mingled excitement and terror.

 

Mark’s marathon

1 2 3 4 5 6
Slideshow Bootstrap by WOWSlider.com v3.9

On Sunday 2nd June I left early for the Fallen Rocks car park to join a small support group that had gathered to meet and greet Mark Beaumont, who was preparing for his 6 mile swim across the Clyde to Rothesay Promenade on Bute. When Mark and his own team arrived, we all headed off to walk the 2 miles to the Fallen Rocks by the forestry road and path. The gate was opened for the support vehicles and for the local coastguards who were on stand-by.


From Kathmandu to Lochranza

On Saturday June 8th, the Nepalese Ambassador, Dr Chalise, was at the Lochranza Distillery to open an exhibition of work by sixteen Nepali children who had worked in a two-month-long project with Gordon Davidson. Also present was Sunita Podder, the newly appointed Consul for Scotland. Gordon’s own evocative paintings of Nepal combined with the children’s work to create a strong impression of this mountainous, beautiful country.

Gordon, who has a house in Corrie, is a world traveller of the best kind, and has a history of involvement in schemes to help local people. The current one arises from an exhibition for the ‘Nepal 2011 - Year of Tourism’ celebrations, aimed at getting people to come back to Nepal after their civil war. It was held in the Gurkha museum in Winchester and went very well, and the following year, the Gurkhas asked Gordon if he could set up an art project with the Happy Children Home in the small town of Budhanilkantha, north of Kathmandu in Nepal.

With touching honesty, Gordon admits that he’d ‘never really liked wee kids’ - and to make things harder, they spoke no English and he spoke no Nepali and had to use an interpreter. None of it mattered. Throughout November and December he worked with the sixteen children ‘harder than I’ve ever done in my life’ and says, ‘it turned out to be an amazing adventure.’ Some of them had great ability but they knew nothing about drawing and mixing colours because art is not taught in Nepali schools. They didn’t have toys or TV, either, so ‘Art was a big change for them.’ Gordon adds, ‘Every day something would come along that made you want to cry it was so sad... but every day we laughed eight or nine times over something really funny.’ To his surprise, he came to love the children, who clearly adored him. ‘They were such poor wee things, you could help but like them … The day I left most of them cried, which was very sad.’

Gordon brought back 80 of the children’s paintings to sell throughout the year, raising money that will go back to the Home and pay for further art materials, enabling the project to keep going. He stays in touch with the children through Skype, and hopes to hold further exhibitions of their work every year. He has sent photos of the Lochranza show to them, and says they are ‘really amazed.’

 

Poem of the month

selected by David Underdown

Lines from Endymion

by John Keats (1795-1821)

A thing of beauty is a joy for ever:
Its loveliness increases; it will never
Pass into nothingness; but still will keep
A bower quiet for us, and a sleep
Full of sweet dreams, and health, and quiet breathing.
Therefore, on every morrow, are we wreathing
A flowery band to bind us to the earth,
Spite of despondence, of the inhuman dearth
Of noble natures, of the gloomy days,
Of all the unhealthy and o’er-darkened ways
Made for our searching: yes, in spite of all,
Some shape of beauty moves away the pall
From our dark spirits.

This is an extract from Keats’s epic poem Endymion. It was written when he was still only twenty-three, a year before he met Fanny Brawne and started to produce the shorter poems for which he is famous. Not many people read Endymion nowadays. At 4000 lines it challenges the attention span of the modern reader, and its classical subject matter, couched in strongly rhymed heroic couplets, is unfashionable. And yet its opening line is as familiar (and true) as any in the English language.

 

Fracking may be closer than we think

Friends of the Earth supply an interactive map showing where existing licences for fracking have been granted, and also areas that are under consideration for this alarming technology. We in Scotland have tended to assume that we do not come into these proposals - but we do. An existing licence covers a tract of land running from Glasgow through Stirling and spreads north-east as far as Glenrothes and Cupar. This means any application to set up hydraulic fracturing to mine natural gas will go ahead unchallenged.

More ominous from the Arran point of view is the area designated for potential fracking. This, coloured lime green on the map, begins just across the water in Largs and covers Bute and Cumbrae, Rothesay, Dunoon, Garelochhead and a wide swathe of territory running north of Loch Lomond into the Trossachs.

 

SEPA on the hook over Slice pollution

ForAgyll.com asserts that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) has case to answer. Information obtained under Freedom of Information by the Salmon and Trout Association Scotland (S&TAS) as FoI reveals breaches of Environmental Quality Standards at nearly one in five fish farms.

Slice - emamectin benzoate - is routinely used against sea-lice in caged fish, but it is toxic to lobster, crabs and prawns. Data from 146 fish-farms that used Slice between January 2011 and September 2012 were obtained by the S&TAS. At 28 of those farms (19.1%), Environmental Quality Standards were breached.

The results are broadly in line with an earlier study by the S&TAS based on data obtained under FoI and covering 2005 to 2010. At that time, the Environment Minister responsible, Stewart Stevenson MSP, said that if Environmental Quality Standards for sea louse chemicals were breached, SEPA would take steps to rectify the situation. These would include a limit on the further release of these substances until residue levels reduced to ‘below identified safe levels.’

The S&TAS has not seen any sign of SEPA varying the conditions of any fish-farm licence to reduce chemical residues. Marine Harvest is the biggest fish farm operator in Scotland and has been short-listed for the Stewardship Award in the Crown Estate sponsored Marine Aquaculture Awards 2013 - yet 15 of the 28 fish-farms with samples in breach of Environmental Quality Standards for Slice are operated by Marine Harvest (Scotland) Limited.

ForArgyll points to what it calls ‘the Catch 22 of open cage intensive aquaculture.’ Heavy sea lice infestation is common in the dense populations of caged fish, and also presents a serious threat to wild salmon and trout fisheries. Free swimming sea lice around the cages - often in waters through which migrating salmonids must travel - are fatal to the vulnerable juveniles on which the futures of the fisheries depend.

But if the cage populations are drenched with Slice to keep the sea lice under control, though wild fish may benefit in the short term, sea bed residues of these chemicals threaten wild crustaceans, which are particularly susceptible to Slice. Lobster, crab and creel fishermen operating in the loch systems are acutely aware of this, seeing their catches dwindle where salmon farms are using emamectin benzoate.

The only real solution is to use closed containment salmon farming. Meanwhile, SEPA has a serious case to answer for its neglect of the responsibilities on which its existence is assumed to rest.

 

Katy Clark attacks employment tribunal fees …

Our constantly busy Member of Parliament, Katy Clark spoke out this week on the Government’s proposals to introduce fees for employment tribunals. From 29th July this year anyone seeking to bring a case against an employer to an employment tribunal will be charged a fee, and Katy points out that this may in many cases make the procedure impossible. She said, ‘The Government is yet again taking action which has the potential to hurt employees across the UK. This change will act as a disincentive for those who have been poorly treated in the workplace to stand up for their rights and will allow unscrupulous employers to go unpunished.’ She added, ‘Instead of slashing workers’ rights [the Government] should instead be looking at implementing a credible plan for jobs and growth.’

 

… and defends the badgers

In a letter to the Voice, Katy Clark said, ‘I share your concern about the badger cull. … As you say, the overwhelming majority of scientific opinion does not support a cull as a means of reducing bovine TB.’ She continued, ‘In 2008 the last Government decided against culling as a means of bovine TB control in light of scientific evidence against it. Instead funding was allocated to develop vaccinations for bovine TB. This, alongside revised cattle movement restrictions, would be a far better long-term solution.’ Fortunately for Scottish badgers, the question is a devolved matter, and north of the border, they are safe from slaughter. How long before we see badgers wearing YES campaign waistcoats?

 

Jan’s kitchen

Jan Inglis sends us another summery recipe - simple and delicious.

Mushrooms à la Greque

Ingredients

Button mushrooms 12 oz (350 grms)
1 large tomato
2 garlic cloves, finely chopped
Juice of 2 lemons
2 tbsp (30 ml.) olive oil
1 bay leaf
1 sprig of parsley
Salt and pepper to taste
¼ pint (150 ml.) water
Chopped parsley to garnish

Method

Put everything except the mushrooms and tomato into a saucepan, with the water.
Bring to the boil and continue to boil for 5 mins.
Add the mushrooms and simmer, covered , for a further 5 mins.
Add the chopped tomato.
Remove from the heat and when cool, refrigerate until really cold.
Sprinkle with chopped parsley before serving.

This can be eaten as a starter or as a salad.

 

The Veggie Table

David Simpkin gives advice on growing your own food crops

Watch out for blight and the grey mould, botrytis, as the weather turns warm and humid. Especially if plants are under cover, improving air-flow will help to create drier conditions and protect against these afflictions. To help prevent blight, Bordeaux mixture can be applied to potatoes and tomatoes now, then again in a few weeks. I would add seaweed concentrate to the mix and spray onto the foliage. Seaweed concentrate sprayed on everything green in the garden gives a real fillip to all plants and helps them to resist infection and pests. Spraying once a month will keep them strong and healthy.

Another fantastic food for your plants is a ‘tea’ made from comfrey left to stand in water for a week. It smells as foul as pig poo but your plants will love it! If you have space in your garden for a permanent comfrey patch, try to get ‘Bocking 14’ which is nutritionally superior to other strains. Autumn peas like Kelvedon Wonder should be sown now, and it’s worth chancing another sowing of mange- tout. Further sowings of lettuce, endives, turnip and beetroot can be attempted too.

Kohl Rabi is a very useful crop that can be started now. When young the globes can be grated raw onto salads and the leaves used like spinach. Older ones are great in soups and stews. Chinese cabbage can be sown in situ to be used in the coming autumn, and so can spring cabbage like Durham Early, which will give you a good crop for use next year.

To encourage youngsters to garden, get them to grow radishes, which are unfailingly obliging. The smaller varieties can be sown in seed trays on your windowsill.

 


Post Office workers don’t want to be privatised

In a recent ballot, 96% of Post Office workers voted to remain in public ownership, even though they have been promised £1,500 in shares if the sale goes through. They point to the fact that the Royal Mail has doubled its profits lately, and though the result of a ‘fattening-up’ process for privatisation, it shows that the Post Office is still a valuable and necessary service. We, their customers, are grateful. The UK has the highest level of post box provision per square kilometre of any Western European nation. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

Katy Clark MP describes selling off the Post Office as ‘a massive mistake.’ She says: ‘The six-day delivery service could be under threat and would be less secure if Royal Mail is transferred into private ownership. The Government claim that the universal service is enshrined in law, but many aspects of the universal service obligation are set by the regulator and can be easily changed. The track record of the regulator to date does not inspire confidence. We already know that they are allowing TNT to cherry pick services in London, employing staff on zero hour contracts and far worse terms and conditions and with lower standards of service, to undercut Royal Mail. Whilst TNT and other organisations may wish to take on easier and more profitable routes, it is unlikely they will be willing to take on more remote and rural communities.’

 

Norway in a salmon rumpus

The Norwegian newspaper VG (pictured below) had a front page on June10th that said, “Do not give salmon to children”. It quoted Anne-Lise Birch Monsen(also pictured), who is a specialist in paediatrics at Haukeland University Hospital. The Bergen News revealed later that Anne-Lise has for years been in conflict with a fish-farming company at her holiday home in Sveio.

The VG editor Torry Pedersen didn’t know this, but assumed that such an experienced specialist would distinguish between research and any private concerns.

 

People pay more for line-caught fish.

EU Fish news reports that we are willing to pay up to 22% extra for a packet of frozen cod or haddock when it is labelled ‘line-caught’. A four-year market survey financed by the Norwegian Seafood Research Fund (FHF) recorded weekly sales of almost 100 frozen fish products in seven British supermarkets, and concluded that ‘line-caught fish is often of better quality than fish captured by other modes … and represents values that consumers want.’

 

Book review

Sally Campbell sends us this review of The Great Tax Robbery, by Richard Brooks

Richard Brooks, whose book is subtitled How Britain became a tax haven for fat cats and big business, quotes Oliver Wendell Holmes, an American Supreme Court Judge, who said in 1927, ‘I like paying taxes. With them I buy civilisation.’ Perhaps the idea reassured him, for when he first contemplated writing a book on tax avoidance, the prospect of turning over 40% of the potentially dazzling profits to the taxman was slightly deflating. Then he thought of the return on his tax investment, and realised that every pound paid in tax would bring the following benefits:

7p for immediate access to professional healthcare for his family
5p for his children’s education
2p for living in relative security
2p approximately for national defence
11p for pensions and social security for his compatriots and his future self
½p to aid the developing world
3p in interest to the various institutions from which we collectively have borrowed

Brooks does not doubt the overall value he gets for his money.

We hear a great deal about small-scale tax evasion such as cash-in-hand plumbing, piano lessons, hairdressing etc. We are also aware of the offshore accounts and dodgy invoices hidden from the taxman. Evasion of these direct taxes costs the UK treasury some £40bn annually, and more if you include evasion of indirect taxes such as VAT. But this is nothing compared with the systematic tax avoidance now being tackled by the Public Accounts Committee under chair Margaret Hodge MP.

Richard Brooks, himself a former tax inspector, wrote his book out of a need to expose how large multinationals regard tax avoidance merely as good financial planning. He charts how the UK has become a global tax haven that serves the super-wealthy, while everyone else picks up the bill. This well written, understandable financial book exposes some shocking facts. Thousands of British state schools and NHS hospitals, for instance, are owned by companies based in offshore tax havens. Multinationals like Google and Starbucks operate almost tax-free in the UK and billions are tucked away in secret Swiss bank accounts.

Brooks rightly questions why it is the little people who are the only ones to pay taxes; why the rich, the multinationals and ‘celebrities’ do not support our country, our schools, our health system and infrastructure, even though they and their employees all use them. His account is shocking and riveting, but highly readable. Without tax input from all people and companies working and living here, the nation cannot hope to reverse the cycle of decline, and it must be asked why the Treasury and Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) turn a blind eye to national and international tax avoidance.

The Great Tax Robbery by Richard Brooks
Oneworld Publications Ltd.
ISBN 978-1-85168-935-4 £12.99
E-book ISBN 978-1-78074-102-4

 

Crossword

Across

 1 Sailor caught in stupid line somehow, and that's a fact! (12)

 8 Racketeer mostly refereed controversially (7)

 9 Get rid of Jamie Oliver's instrument (5)

10 Remove trace of boomerang (5)

11 French novelist's favourite part of the coast? (4)

13 For most of the warm period, no return to rally (6)

15 Calling to Asian country, it's said (6)

17 Nothing more than a lake (4)

18 You French show back-chat about flower (5)

21 Without hesitation, revolutionary gets mixed up in fruit (5)

22 Drums used in Cats (3-4)

23 Can't yet reply to change in minor crime (5, 7)


Preview of McLellan Festival programme

An Arran play for the Festival

Cicely Gill, who lives in Whiting Bay, wrote her first play when she was about 17, inspired by going to the Edinburgh Festival and visiting the Traverse theatre when it was in the High Street to see Ubu Roi. She has been writing ‘on and off’ every since, and this year her one-act play called No Danger from the Cutlery will form part of a double bill in the McLellan Festival.

Cicely wrote the play last autumn. It centres round the question of how people cope (or don’t) when a disabled person is introduced into the family, and features a mother called Antoinette whose reaction to her son’s love for a girl with a deformed foot may bring a wince of recognition to many in the audience. Antoinette, Cicely says, ‘seemed to grow of her own accord.’

The young players who starred so notably in the school production of The Importance of Being Earnest will appear in No Danger from the Cutlery, so the play is in safe hands and promises a further treat to the audience. Robert McLellan’s beautiful and mysterious one-act play, The Carlin Moth, which many people may remember from a production in Corrie Hall some years ago, completes a richly satisfying double bill. Performances will be at the Community Theatre on Friday and Saturday 23rd and 24th August, at the start of the McLellan Festival. Full details in next month’s Voice.

Open Studios - and a bus that serves them all

Following the great success of last year’s Open Studios weekend, when visitors - and interested residents, too - were invited to see Arran artists working in their own studios, the event is being repeated from Friday 16th - Monday 19th August. And, immensely usefully, an Art Bus will run from Brodick pier, leaving at 10:45am and returning at 4:15pm, and calling at a range of different s each day. No map-reading, no tricky parking, you are simply taken on a circular tour of every studio. School age children and full time students travel free, and everyone else pays a mere £5, which is less that it would cost you for the petrol.

More information about the route on each day will be available at www.arranopenstudios.com

 

Coast public meeting

Over 60 people attended a public meeting held by the Community of Arran Seabed Trust (COAST) on Thursday 20th June, to discuss the proposed South Arran Marine Protected Area (MPA). A consultation process starts this July, so it is important that the proposal is understood. The MPA is a critical step towards creating a healthy Clyde that can support sustainable fishing, and it will also protect vital habitats such as maerl (an algae that looks like a coral) and seagrass beds. These beds provide shelter and nursery grounds for species like the juvenile cod and sea cucumbers. Underwater video footage filmed in Arran waters by local diver Howard Wood, who is one of the founders of COAST.

The proposed MPA will run from Corriegills round the South of Arran to the north of Drumadoon point, reinstating the three-mile limit round the south of the island. In this area, damaging fishing techniques such as bottom trawling and dredging will not be allowed, so fragile habitats and fish nursery grounds can develop in peace. The protected area will not be a No Take Zone like the one in Lamlash Bay. Activities such as creeling, sea angling, water sports and swimming will continue, as these do not destroy the seabed, which is the nursery for marine life. For more information, visit the COAST website: www.arrancoast.com or give COAST a call on 01770 600656.

 

Marine News

from John Kinsman

At on the summer solstice, Friday June 21st, Tobermory’s lifeboat crew went to the aid of a diver suffering from decompression sickness, known as ‘the bends’ The call came from 14 miles north of Tobermory on the Isle of Mull. The man was successfully transferred to the lifeboat where he received care from the lifeboat volunteers, and he was then taken to Oban and transferred to the Scottish Ambulance Service shortly after midnight.

Two days later the lifeboat was called out again to assist a 30ft prawn trawler suffering loss of power off Salen in Loch Sunart. Despite 35 knot north-westerly winds, the trawler was towed into Tobermory.

£9,500 fine for under-sized scallops

On June 26th a court in Brighton ordered the Scottish owners and master of the Georgia Dawn (INS140) to pay a total of £9,042 for landing scallops below the minimum landing size. Marine enforcement officers in October of last year found 1.4 metric tonnes (almost 12% of the total catch) of scallops retained on board that were below the minimum landing size of 110 mm.

Ormonde Fishing Ltd of Gallow Hill, Rosshire, Scotland, owners of the boat, paid most of the fine, but the master, David Patience of Peterhead, was fined £500 plus a £50 ‘victim surcharge’. Not that it did the juvenile scallops much good.

 

Recipe from Anne

Almond and Apple Cake
Serves 8

Ingredients.

80g butter, at room temperature.
140g caster sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract.
3 eggs
100g ground almonds
150g self-raising flour
80ml milk
2 small cooking apples, thinly sliced.

Method

Preheat the oven to 170C/Gas Mark 3.
Grease a 22cm cake tin with melted butter, and line base and sides with baking parchment.
Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl until pale and creamy. Add the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition.
Stir in ground almonds. Gradually stir in the flour and milk.
Arrange the apple slices, slightly overlapping, on the base of the cake tin, and cover with the cake mixture.
Bake for 3-35 minutes or until a skewer inserted into centre comes out clean.
Set aside in the pan for 10 minutes to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.
Serve warm.

 

The old hands – still at it

Don MacNeish and Howard Wood were founder members of COAST back in 1995, and here they still are, assisting with a beach clean-up on the shore north of Clauchlands point. Last week, Kristina Boerder and other volunteer friends gathered up and bagged literally boat-loads of rubbish from this beach, the tied bags now waiting to be collected by boat.

This beautiful beach forms part of Arran's Coastal Way, much used by walkers. It features lovely salt marshes and volcanic dykes, and birds nest in the cliffs above the shore.

COAST are always grateful for help with beach cleaning and practical jobs. If you’d like to give a hand, contact Andrew Binnie through the COAST website or on 600 656.

 

Green Party opposes fracking

As so often, the Green Party offers a coherent opposition to the Westminster government’s backing of fracking. MP Caroline Lucas has asked the House of Commons for an urgent debate on the subject, and says, ‘Ministers should spend more time working out how to keep fossil fuels in the ground and less time squandering taxpayers’ money on tax breaks for shale gas.’

Green Party Leader Natalie Bennett agreed, pointing out that as well as the immense consumption of water and the high risk of earthquakes and contaminated aquifers, we must recognise that Britain may not be able to meet its legally binding emissions targets if it embraces fracking. The price to be paid in real terms is very high, whereas the ‘fuel’ for solar panels and wind turbines costs nothing.

The single gas well fracked in Bowland Shale was suspended after it triggered two small earth tremors in the Blackpool area, but nevertheless the government has issued 176 licences for onshore oil and gas exploration.