Issue 93

Hello, and welcome to the December issue of the Voice.

As 2018 draws to a close, the political affairs of the country have been intensifying, particularly around the big issues of climate change and of course Brexit. We have been hearing about some of these matters around the clock while about others we have heard comparatively little.

The climate protestors of Extinction Rebellion, a new environmental mass movement, have been bringing London to a fairly regular standstill over the past couple of weeks with bridge and road occupations, and these types of protests are spreading across the globe. Yet these demonstrations in the capital have been filed away into the regional news corners of the BBC, and many people it seems, at least possibly out-with London, are not aware of the protests happening. Meanwhile Heads of State are preparing to meet for the UN Climate talks in Poland (COP24) at the beginning of December. Will they listen to the messages of those people who are going out onto the street and who are prepared to go to jail for this foremost issue of our time?

In this edition of the Voice, to bring an alternative perspective to the other major and much more visible UK matter, we have an article on the possibilities that Brexit could open up (even if it may seem very unlikely at this point), if the country was to move along the lines of the principles of ‘degrowth’, a concept that argues for a less aggressive approach to economic growth that would lead to a fairer and greener society.

Nearer to home, we take a look at some interesting events that have been happening over the last month in Arran. We have a piece on the visit to COAST by Marine Scotland Compliance, a report from the Arran Community Land Initiative with news from their recent AGM, and a brief update on the reforesting Glen Rosa project. These community initiatives connect in different and pertinent ways to the broader ongoing political and environmental issues. To show just how clear these links often are, we have included a recent article on reforestation by Mark Maslin where he describes in his article on Rewilding the UK, how planting hundreds more trees would significantly help the UK reach its climate targets.

Looking forward, in amongst the Christmas parties there are plenty of things to be doing in the very near festive future in Arran. The Christmas pantomime, this year The Sound of Music, starts on Thursday 6th at the High School and runs till 8th December. There is also a Poetry / COAST night in Brodick on 5th, the launch of a community arts project 52 Stitched Stories on 7th, another Corrie Food Festival, this time with a Winter theme on Saturday 15th, and a children’s drawing competition to enter – see Corrie’s Christmas Art Competition, open until 5th December.

Zooming out again to the national picture, there is of course THE vote taking place in Westminster in the middle of the month. So which way will our MPs vote on 11th? For the Prime Minister’s Agreement or for a No Deal?? At this stage, possibly only Santa knows! We’ll see you on the ‘other side’ in 2019! We hope you enjoy this edition, and from all of us at the Voice, we wish you a very Merry Christmas.

Degrowth is the radical post-Brexit future the UK needs

As the Brexit negotiations wrap up and Theresa May’s deal is lambasted by Remainers and Leavers alike, it’s still far from clear what the future holds for the United Kingdom. On March 29 2019, it is due to leave the European Union.

Brexit is the first time a member state has voted to withdraw from the EU and it has caused a geopolitical earthquake, unleashing uncertainty in the UK and abroad. We don’t know what the impact on the UK will be when (and if) it actually leaves the EU. If it does so on poor terms, or via the still possible “no deal” eventuality, there are a wealth of devastating projections which may materialise.
The only thing that we can be sure of is that Brexit represents a moment of huge social, political and economic rupture. However, history tells us that such moments are also moments of opportunity for radical departure from the status quo.


The Allotments at the Arran Community Land Initiative (ACLI)

On a beautiful November afternoon, The Voice went along to the allotments at the Arran Community Land Initiative in Whiting Bay to spend a couple of hours in the company of some of the plot holders - Helen, Jim, Debbie and Woodie the dog. The 18 plots at the Community Land in Whiting Bay were set up in 2016. The 12 full size allotments, (with three split into half plots to make up the 18), are tended by gardeners with a passion and commitment that is inspiring. In the warmth of the poly tunnel shed, innovatively designed and built by Jim (to adhere to the four feet shed height restrictions), we drank tea, mused over how to deter roaming deer that are partial to brassicas, chatted about the joys of growing your own food and contemplated life up here on the land at ACLI.


Marine Scotland Meet the Community

The Community of Arran Seabed Trust (COAST) hosted Marine Scotland Compliance officers on 8th November.

The seminar, held at the COAST Octopus Centre was fully-booked and attended by members of the public, COAST staff, and volunteers who were interested to hear how they and Marine Scotland Compliance (MSC) staff could best work together to ensure compliance with commercial fishing restrictions in the South Arran Marine Protection Area (MPA). The five MSC staff who attended included the Acting Deputy Director, the Enforcement Team Leader, a Data Analyst and two senior crew members of the inshore Marine Protection Vessel (MPV) Minna.


As cheap as mince for Christmas. How come?

Local marine scientist, activist, and writer Sally Campbell, considers how the price of Scottish salmon can be so low and urges us as consumers to say no to these unrealistic prices that cover a multitude of environmentally damaging and unsustainable fish farming practices.

I was somewhat surprised to see an advert for ASDA on 22 November in a National newspaper for Scottish farmed salmon for £4.97 per kilo for Christmas, making it cheaper than mince at £5.00 per kilogramme. How on earth can a profit margin be made at that price bearing in mind the fish has been growing for up to 3 years, fed, disease controlled, prepared for supermarket, distributed over the country and marketed in the national media, like The Daily Mail? So let’s unpack some of the issues.


Rewilding is essential to the UK’s commitments on climate change

Humans have cut down half the trees on Earth since the dawn of agriculture – over 3 trillion of them. This huge loss holds the potential for massive reforestation today, which would protect local environments from soil loss, flash flooding and desertification and take up large quantities of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Despite these advantages, reforestation gets very little attention in our fight against climate change.

Britain is ideal for tree growth due to its mild winters, plentiful rainfall, fertile soil and hill-sheltered topography, and it has growth rates higher than mainland Europe and Scandinavia.



The Reforesting Glen Rosa Project

November has seen the start of the National Trust project to reforest Glen Rosa. Earlier in the year the National Trust for Scotland unveiled an initiative to plant 32 hectares of native trees in Glen Rosa. The Trust aims to renew the natural habitat for wildlife on the island, as well as ensure the preservation of the Arran Whitebeam – one of the most endangered tree species in the world.

One of Head Ranger Kate Sampson’s big projects for 2018 is to plant native woodland in the area. Trees were once abundant in the area, but overgrazing has seen them disappear from the glen.


Loki to Angela Davis: Scottish readers 10 most rebellious books of the 21st century

THE SCOTTISH BOOK TRUST has announced its reader-voted list of the top ten “most rebellious reads of the 21st century”, with Orwell Prize-winning Glasgow writer and performer Darren McGarvey’s Poverty Safari emerging as the front-runner.

The list also includes the 2017 feminist anthology Nasty Women, published to great acclaim by the award-winning Scottish independent publisher 404 Ink.

The new ranking comes as part of Book Week Scotland (which ran from 19 - 23rd November), now in its seventh year and overseen by the national literature and literacy charity the Scottish Book Trust. As part of Book Week Scotland’s 2018 theme ‘Rebel,’ readers were asked to select their most rebellious read from a shortlist of 21 non-fiction books, with a record 3,500 participating in the poll.


Poetry event with an ocean theme

A message from Arran Poets and COAST...

This is to invite you to a poetry gig at 7.30 pm on Thursday 6th December in the Brodick Bar. As usual we are holding our poetry celebration out of step with the rest of the country which does National Poetry Day in October. This year we are making the event a little different and asking for all contributions to relate to the sea in some way or other, be it fishing, fish, seaweed or sea bathing, rock, sand or tide, boat, ship or ferry or anything else you can think of.


Corrie Film Club in December

Corrie Film Club Christmas Programme

On Sunday 9th December, the programme will begin at 7.00pm.

Dinner for One (Director Heinz Dunkhause 1963. Germany. 18 mins Cert U)

Dinner for One is a traditional Christmas short comedy (and will be served with mulled wine).

At Miss Sophie's 90th birthday dinner, her butler James must fill in for her four departed friends - and that includes lots of drinks before every course!

Dinner for One - staring Freddie Frinton - was filmed by a German TV company in 1963. It has been shown every New Year's Eve on German TV since 1972, winning it a place in the Guinness Book of Records. Frinton originally performed the sketch on stage in Blackpool, but it was turned into an 18-minute film for German television.



52 Stitched Stories Community Arts Project

52 Stitched Stories – Community arts project with Earth Threads

Launch event – Friday 7th December at Coast in Whiting Bay anytime between 11 and 2pm.

This project is open to all. The ambition is for everyone involved to create a textile postcard once a week during 2019. The 52 postcards are designed to reflect individual’s personal narratives throughout the year. Inspiration can come from anywhere and anything. Changing seasons, life events, emotions, activities or simply just a colour. These are just some examples of ideas. Postcards can be made using any textile medium. The hope is that we will be able to share our collective 52 stitched stories in 2020. We hope to meet monthly throughout the project to share our work in progress and support each other. Come along to the launch event to find out more and consider joining us with your starter pack.


Music Matters in Lamlash

MUSIC MATTERS AT LAMLASH CHURCH HALL

By the Rev. Lily McKinnon

Research shows that people living with dementia (and their carers) can become isolated and disconnected from the outside world. This can lead to frustration, depression, and aggression. Being more active in participation with others in stimulating activities has an uplifting effect, calms people and enables a sense of well-being. These aspects of dementia care and interaction are often overlooked in dealing with the demanding day to day personal care. For some carers it is 24/7 and lack of sleep, and lack of socialising can have a detrimental effect on them and on the care they are able to provide at home.


Arran Community Land Initiative (ACLI) AGM sets out plans for coming year

There was a full house for the ACLI AGM, held on November 14th in Whiting Bay Village Hall. ACLI covers an area of 35 hectares of disused farmland in Whiting Bay and was the first Community Buy-out on Arran. It was purchased in December 2014 with monies from the Scottish Land Fund. The aim of acquiring the land was to advance education, training and skill development, as well as recreational activities and food production by community members. The AGM was led by the Chairperson, Rob Cowieson, who stressed the charitable status of the organisation and outlined its purpose and aims, as stated in its constitution. He stated that decision-making about future ACLI developments should be with these purposes clearly in mind and also take into account available skills and funding. Projects should be viable, and where possible, sustainable.


Antarctica Ocean Sanctuary – ‘Not this year’

A report from Sally Campbell on the latest developments concerning the Antartica Ocean Sanctuary

A plan to turn a huge tract of pristine Antarctic ocean into the world’s biggest sanctuary has been rejected, throwing the future of one of the Earth’s most important ecosystems into doubt. The 1.8m sq km reserve – five times the size of Germany – would have banned all fishing in a vast area of the Weddell Sea and parts of the Antarctic peninsula, safeguarding species including penguins, killer whales, leopard seals and blue whales. Experts said it would also have played a key role in tackling climate change, as the seas around the Antarctic soak up huge amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. But following days of talks in October in Hobart in Tasmania, the Antarctic Ocean Commission (CCAMLR) rejected the plan, which needed unanimous agreement to pass. Environmental groups said Russia, China and Norway had played a part in blocking the proposal, with the other 22 members of the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources, the organisation set up to protect Antarctic waters, backing the proposal.


Corrie’s Christmas Art Competition

Children aged 8 and under are invited to send in a Christmas painting or drawing of Corrie in their favourite place in Scotland. Using paper or card no bigger than A4 size and completed in pencil or paint.

A prize bundle of Corrie’s Capers goodies will be awarded including a signed copy of “The Westie Fest” book, a poster, coasters, stickers and a badge.

Also, a visit to ‘The Parlour’ for an Isle of Arran ice cream with the author if you can get to Brodick under your own steam! (sorry, t&s costs are not included in this prize)


Marine News

From John Kinsman, at St Monan’s Coastwatch, East Fife.

Ship Transporting Live Fish Breaks Down

The crew of a ship carrying live fish had to be rescued on Tuesday November 14th after the vessel broke down. The MVF Migdale with four persons on board got into difficulty close to Ardnamurchan point. The skipper dropped anchor at the end of the Sound of Mull while waiting assistance. The Migdale was then towed to Mallaig by another vessel in the early hours of Wednesday 15th November and Tobermory Lifeboat offered assistance.